add tests for governor mutation

agora-specs/Sample/Governor/Mutate.hs

@@ -0,0 +1,264 @@
+module Sample.Governor.Mutate (
+  -- * Testing Utilities
+  GovernorOutputDatumValidity (..),
+  GATValidity (..),
+  GovernorParameters (..),
+  MockEffectParameters (..),
+  ParameterBundle (..),
+
+  -- * Testing Utilities
+  Validity (..),
+  mutate,
+  mkTestCase,
+
+  -- * Parameters Bundles
+  totallyValidBundle,
+  invalidBundles,
+) where
+
+import Agora.Effect.NoOp (noOpValidator)
+import Agora.Governor (GovernorDatum (..), GovernorRedeemer (MutateGovernor))
+import Agora.Governor.Scripts (governorValidator)
+import Agora.Proposal (ProposalId (ProposalId), ProposalThresholds (..))
+import Agora.Utils (validatorHashToTokenName)
+import Data.Default (def)
+import Plutarch.Api.V1 (PValidator, mkValidator, validatorHash)
+import Plutarch.Context (
+  BaseBuilder,
+  buildTxInfoUnsafe,
+  input,
+  mint,
+  output,
+  pubKey,
+  script,
+  withDatum,
+  withOutRef,
+  withValue,
+ )
+import PlutusLedgerApi.V1 (
+  Data,
+  ScriptContext (ScriptContext),
+  ScriptPurpose (Spending),
+  TxInfo,
+  TxOutRef (TxOutRef),
+  ValidatorHash,
+  Value,
+  toData,
+ )
+import PlutusLedgerApi.V1.Value qualified as Value
+import Sample.Shared (
+  authorityTokenSymbol,
+  govAssetClass,
+  govValidatorHash,
+  governor,
+  minAda,
+ )
+import Test.Specification (SpecificationTree, testValidator)
+import Test.Util (pubKeyHashes, sortValue, validatorHashes, withOptional)
+
+--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
+
+data GovernorOutputDatumValidity
+  = DatumValid
+  | ValueInvalid
+  | WrongType
+  | NoDatum
+  deriving stock (Bounded, Enum)
+
+data GATValidity
+  = GATValid
+  | WrongTag
+  | NoGAT
+  deriving stock (Bounded, Enum)
+
+data GovernorParameters = GovernorParameters
+  { governorOutputDatumValidity :: GovernorOutputDatumValidity
+  , stealGST :: Bool
+  }
+
+data MockEffectParameters = MockEffectParameters
+  { gatValidity :: GATValidity
+  , burnGAT :: Bool
+  }
+
+data ParameterBundle = ParameterBundle
+  { governorParameters :: GovernorParameters
+  , mockEffectParameters :: MockEffectParameters
+  }
+
+newtype Validity = Validity {forGovernorValidator :: Bool}
+
+--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
+
+governorInputDatum :: GovernorDatum
+governorInputDatum =
+  GovernorDatum
+    { proposalThresholds = def
+    , nextProposalId = ProposalId 0
+    , proposalTimings = def
+    , createProposalTimeRangeMaxWidth = def
+    , maximumProposalsPerStake = 3
+    }
+
+mkGovernorOutputDatum ::
+  GovernorOutputDatumValidity ->
+  Maybe Data
+mkGovernorOutputDatum DatumValid =
+  Just $
+    toData $
+      governorInputDatum
+        { maximumProposalsPerStake = 4
+        }
+mkGovernorOutputDatum ValueInvalid =
+  let invalidProposalThresholds =
+        ProposalThresholds
+          { execute = -1
+          , create = -1
+          , vote = -1
+          }
+   in Just $
+        toData $
+          governorInputDatum
+            { proposalThresholds =
+                invalidProposalThresholds
+            }
+mkGovernorOutputDatum WrongType = Just $ toData ()
+mkGovernorOutputDatum NoDatum = Nothing
+
+governorRef :: TxOutRef
+governorRef =
+  TxOutRef
+    "6cce6dfbb697f9e2c4fe9786bb576eb7bd6cbcf7801a4ba13d596006c2d5b957"
+    1
+
+governorScriptPurpose :: ScriptPurpose
+governorScriptPurpose = Spending governorRef
+
+governorRedeemer :: GovernorRedeemer
+governorRedeemer = MutateGovernor
+
+mkGovernorBuilder :: GovernorParameters -> BaseBuilder
+mkGovernorBuilder ps =
+  let gst = Value.assetClassValue govAssetClass 1
+      value = sortValue $ gst <> minAda
+      gstOutput =
+        if ps.stealGST
+          then pubKey $ head pubKeyHashes
+          else script govValidatorHash
+      withGSTDatum =
+        withOptional withDatum $
+          mkGovernorOutputDatum ps.governorOutputDatumValidity
+   in mconcat
+        [ input $
+            script govValidatorHash
+              . withDatum governorInputDatum
+              . withValue value
+              . withOutRef governorRef
+        , output $
+            gstOutput
+              . withGSTDatum
+              . withValue value
+        ]
+
+--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
+
+mockEffectValidator :: ClosedTerm PValidator
+mockEffectValidator = noOpValidator authorityTokenSymbol
+
+mockEffectValidatorHash :: ValidatorHash
+mockEffectValidatorHash = validatorHash $ mkValidator mockEffectValidator
+
+mkGATValue :: GATValidity -> Integer -> Value
+mkGATValue NoGAT _ = mempty
+mkGATValue v q =
+  let gatOwner = case v of
+        GATValid -> mockEffectValidatorHash
+        WrongTag -> head validatorHashes
+   in Value.singleton
+        authorityTokenSymbol
+        (validatorHashToTokenName gatOwner)
+        q
+
+mkMockEffectBuilder :: MockEffectParameters -> BaseBuilder
+mkMockEffectBuilder ps =
+  let mkGATValue' = mkGATValue ps.gatValidity
+      inputValue = mkGATValue' 1
+      outputValue = inputValue <> burnt
+      burnt =
+        if ps.burnGAT
+          then mkGATValue' (-1)
+          else mempty
+   in mconcat
+        [ mint burnt
+        , input $
+            script mockEffectValidatorHash
+              . withValue inputValue
+        , output $
+            script mockEffectValidatorHash
+              . withValue outputValue
+        ]
+
+--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
+
+mutate :: ParameterBundle -> TxInfo
+mutate pb =
+  buildTxInfoUnsafe $
+    mconcat
+      [ mkGovernorBuilder pb.governorParameters
+      , mkMockEffectBuilder pb.mockEffectParameters
+      ]
+
+--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
+
+mkTestCase :: String -> ParameterBundle -> Validity -> SpecificationTree
+mkTestCase name pb (Validity forGov) =
+  testValidator
+    forGov
+    name
+    (governorValidator governor)
+    governorInputDatum
+    governorRedeemer
+    ( ScriptContext
+        (mutate pb)
+        governorScriptPurpose
+    )
+
+--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
+
+totallyValidBundle :: ParameterBundle
+totallyValidBundle =
+  ParameterBundle
+    { governorParameters =
+        GovernorParameters
+          { governorOutputDatumValidity = DatumValid
+          , stealGST = False
+          }
+    , mockEffectParameters =
+        MockEffectParameters
+          { gatValidity = GATValid
+          , burnGAT = True
+          }
+    }
+
+--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
+
+invalidBundles :: [ParameterBundle]
+invalidBundles = do
+  gdv <- enumFrom ValueInvalid
+  sg <- [True, False]
+  gtv <- enumFrom WrongTag
+  bgt <- [True, False]
+
+  pure $
+    ParameterBundle
+      { governorParameters =
+          GovernorParameters
+            { governorOutputDatumValidity = gdv
+            , stealGST = sg
+            }
+      , mockEffectParameters =
+          MockEffectParameters
+            { gatValidity = gtv
+            , burnGAT = bgt
+            }
+      }

agora-specs/Spec/Governor.hs

@@ -13,17 +13,11 @@ TODO: Add negative test cases, see [#76](https://github.com/Liqwid-Labs/agora/is
 -}
 module Spec.Governor (specs) where
 
-import Agora.Governor (GovernorDatum (..), GovernorRedeemer (..))
-import Agora.Governor.Scripts (governorValidator)
-import Agora.Proposal (ProposalId (..))
-import Data.Default.Class (Default (def))
-import Sample.Governor (mintGATs, mutateState)
 import Sample.Governor.Initialize qualified as GST
-import Sample.Shared qualified as Shared
+import Sample.Governor.Mutate qualified as Mutate
 import Test.Specification (
   SpecificationTree,
   group,
-  validatorSucceedsWith,
  )
 
 -- | The SpecificationTree exported by this module.
@@ -48,29 +42,21 @@ specs =
       ]
   , group
       "validator"
-      [ validatorSucceedsWith
+      [ group
-          "GATs minting"
+          "mutate"
-          (governorValidator Shared.governor)
+          [ Mutate.mkTestCase
-          ( GovernorDatum
+              "legal"
-              def
+              Mutate.totallyValidBundle
-              (ProposalId 5)
+              (Mutate.Validity True)
-              def
+          , group "illegal" $
-              def
+              map
-              3
+                ( \b ->
-          )
+                    Mutate.mkTestCase
-          MintGATs
+                      "(negative test)"
-          mintGATs
+                      b
-      , validatorSucceedsWith
+                      (Mutate.Validity False)
-          "mutate governor state"
+                )
-          (governorValidator Shared.governor)
+                Mutate.invalidBundles
-          ( GovernorDatum
+          ]
-              def
-              (ProposalId 5)
-              def
-              def
-              3
-          )
-          MutateGovernor
-          mutateState
       ]
   ]

agora-testlib/Test/Util.hs

@@ -19,6 +19,7 @@ module Test.Util (
   scriptCredentials,
   validatorHashes,
   groupsOfN,
+  withOptional,
 ) where
 
 --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
@@ -31,6 +32,7 @@ import Data.ByteString qualified as BS
 import Data.ByteString.Char8 qualified as C
 import Data.ByteString.Lazy qualified as ByteString.Lazy
 import Data.List (sortOn)
+import Plutarch.Context (UTXO)
 import Plutarch.Crypto (pblake2b_256)
 import PlutusLedgerApi.V1 (Credential (PubKeyCredential, ScriptCredential), PubKeyHash (..), ValidatorHash (ValidatorHash))
 import PlutusLedgerApi.V1.Interval qualified as PlutusTx
@@ -156,3 +158,13 @@ groupsOfN n xs =
     next n (x : xs) =
       let (xs', rest) = next (n - 1) xs
        in (x : xs', rest)
+
+--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
+
+withOptional ::
+  (a -> UTXO -> UTXO) ->
+  Maybe a ->
+  UTXO ->
+  UTXO
+withOptional f (Just b) = f b
+withOptional _ _ = id

agora.cabal

@@ -189,6 +189,7 @@ library agora-specs
     Sample.Effect.TreasuryWithdrawal
     Sample.Governor
     Sample.Governor.Initialize
+    Sample.Governor.Mutate
     Sample.Proposal.Advance
     Sample.Proposal.Cosign
     Sample.Proposal.Create

agora/Agora/Governor/Scripts.hs

@@ -593,7 +593,10 @@ governorValidator gov =
 
         Just MutateGovernor -> unTermCont $ do
           -- Check that a GAT is burnt.
-          pure $ popaque $ singleAuthorityTokenBurned patSymbol txInfoF.inputs txInfoF.mint
+          pguardC "One valid GAT burnt" $
+            singleAuthorityTokenBurned patSymbol txInfoF.inputs txInfoF.mint
+
+          pure $ popaque $ pconstant ()
 
         --------------------------------------------------------------------------
         Nothing -> ptraceError "Unknown redeemer"

bench.csv

@@ -2,18 +2,18 @@ name,cpu,mem,size
 Agora/Effects/Treasury Withdrawal Effect/effect/Simple,333137234,829671,3674
 Agora/Effects/Treasury Withdrawal Effect/effect/Simple with multiple treasuries ,492197164,1196783,3986
 Agora/Effects/Treasury Withdrawal Effect/effect/Mixed Assets,455817227,1103968,3859
-Agora/Effects/Governor Mutation Effect/validator/valid new governor datum/governor validator should pass,92825132,256078,8257
+Agora/Effects/Governor Mutation Effect/validator/valid new governor datum/governor validator should pass,93089688,256879,8290
 Agora/Effects/Governor Mutation Effect/validator/valid new governor datum/effect validator should pass,112671240,312571,3751
 Agora/Stake/policy/stakeCreation,51008580,149029,2522
 Agora/Stake/validator/stakeDepositWithdraw deposit,183506412,498838,4745
 Agora/Stake/validator/stakeDepositWithdraw withdraw,183506412,498838,4733
 Agora/Proposal/policy (proposal creation)/legal/proposal,33689644,100286,2005
-Agora/Proposal/policy (proposal creation)/legal/governor,324511293,861435,8736
+Agora/Proposal/policy (proposal creation)/legal/governor,324511293,861435,8769
 Agora/Proposal/policy (proposal creation)/legal/stake,153960499,403133,5407
 Agora/Proposal/policy (proposal creation)/illegal/invalid next proposal id/proposal,33689644,100286,2005
 Agora/Proposal/policy (proposal creation)/illegal/invalid next proposal id/stake,153960499,403133,5407
 Agora/Proposal/policy (proposal creation)/illegal/use other's stake/proposal,33689644,100286,1974
-Agora/Proposal/policy (proposal creation)/illegal/use other's stake/governor,324511293,861435,8705
+Agora/Proposal/policy (proposal creation)/illegal/use other's stake/governor,324511293,861435,8738
 Agora/Proposal/policy (proposal creation)/illegal/altered stake/proposal,33689644,100286,2005
 Agora/Proposal/policy (proposal creation)/illegal/invalid stake locks/proposal,33689644,100286,2013
 Agora/Proposal/policy (proposal creation)/illegal/invalid stake locks/stake,159394159,417783,5415
@@ -53,7 +53,7 @@ Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 1 cosigners and 1 effects/legal/to next
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 1 cosigners and 1 effects/legal/to next state/from VotingReady to Locked/stake,130046736,336404,5558
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 1 cosigners and 1 effects/legal/to next state/from Locked to Finished/proposal,340029740,936478,10019
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 1 cosigners and 1 effects/legal/to next state/from Locked to Finished/stake,180556487,455715,6710
-Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 1 cosigners and 1 effects/legal/to next state/from Locked to Finished/governor,458676371,1153000,10052
+Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 1 cosigners and 1 effects/legal/to next state/from Locked to Finished/governor,458676371,1153000,10085
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 1 cosigners and 1 effects/legal/to next state/from Locked to Finished/authority,15806303,48240,3653
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 1 cosigners and 1 effects/legal/to failed state/from Draft to Finished/proposal,243781894,681753,8860
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 1 cosigners and 1 effects/legal/to failed state/from Draft to Finished/stake,130046736,336404,5553
@@ -71,9 +71,9 @@ Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 1 cosigners and 1 effects/illegal/ambigu
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 1 cosigners and 1 effects/illegal/to next state too late/from Draft/stake,129324200,334140,5553
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 1 cosigners and 1 effects/illegal/to next state too late/from VotingReady/stake,130046736,336404,5558
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 1 cosigners and 1 effects/illegal/to next state too late/from Locked/stake,180556487,455715,6710
-Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 1 cosigners and 1 effects/illegal/to next state too late/from Locked/governor,458676371,1153000,10052
+Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 1 cosigners and 1 effects/illegal/to next state too late/from Locked/governor,458676371,1153000,10085
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 1 cosigners and 1 effects/illegal/to next state too late/from Locked/authority,15806303,48240,3653
-Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 1 cosigners and 1 effects/illegal/altered output stake datum/from Locked/governor,458676371,1153000,10053
+Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 1 cosigners and 1 effects/illegal/altered output stake datum/from Locked/governor,458676371,1153000,10086
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 1 cosigners and 1 effects/illegal/altered output stake datum/from Locked/authority,15806303,48240,3654
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 1 cosigners and 1 effects/illegal/forget to mint GATs/proposal,315778694,863869,9307
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 1 cosigners and 1 effects/illegal/forget to mint GATs/stake,167456328,430104,5998
@@ -94,7 +94,7 @@ Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 1 cosigners and 2 effects/legal/to next
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 1 cosigners and 2 effects/legal/to next state/from VotingReady to Locked/stake,130046736,336404,5951
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 1 cosigners and 2 effects/legal/to next state/from Locked to Finished/proposal,385431088,1054570,10609
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 1 cosigners and 2 effects/legal/to next state/from Locked to Finished/stake,180556487,455715,7104
-Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 1 cosigners and 2 effects/legal/to next state/from Locked to Finished/governor,478594542,1207445,10446
+Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 1 cosigners and 2 effects/legal/to next state/from Locked to Finished/governor,478594542,1207445,10479
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 1 cosigners and 2 effects/legal/to next state/from Locked to Finished/authority,15806303,48240,4047
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 1 cosigners and 2 effects/legal/to failed state/from Draft to Finished/proposal,289183242,799845,9449
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 1 cosigners and 2 effects/legal/to failed state/from Draft to Finished/stake,130046736,336404,5946
@@ -112,9 +112,9 @@ Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 1 cosigners and 2 effects/illegal/ambigu
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 1 cosigners and 2 effects/illegal/to next state too late/from Draft/stake,129324200,334140,5946
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 1 cosigners and 2 effects/illegal/to next state too late/from VotingReady/stake,130046736,336404,5951
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 1 cosigners and 2 effects/illegal/to next state too late/from Locked/stake,180556487,455715,7104
-Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 1 cosigners and 2 effects/illegal/to next state too late/from Locked/governor,478594542,1207445,10446
+Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 1 cosigners and 2 effects/illegal/to next state too late/from Locked/governor,478594542,1207445,10479
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 1 cosigners and 2 effects/illegal/to next state too late/from Locked/authority,15806303,48240,4047
-Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 1 cosigners and 2 effects/illegal/altered output stake datum/from Locked/governor,478594542,1207445,10447
+Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 1 cosigners and 2 effects/illegal/altered output stake datum/from Locked/governor,478594542,1207445,10480
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 1 cosigners and 2 effects/illegal/altered output stake datum/from Locked/authority,15806303,48240,4048
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 1 cosigners and 2 effects/illegal/forget to mint GATs/proposal,361180042,981961,9897
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 1 cosigners and 2 effects/illegal/forget to mint GATs/stake,167456328,430104,6392
@@ -135,7 +135,7 @@ Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 1 cosigners and 5 effects/legal/to next
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 1 cosigners and 5 effects/legal/to next state/from VotingReady to Locked/stake,130046736,336404,7132
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 1 cosigners and 5 effects/legal/to next state/from Locked to Finished/proposal,521635132,1408846,12380
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 1 cosigners and 5 effects/legal/to next state/from Locked to Finished/stake,180556487,455715,8284
-Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 1 cosigners and 5 effects/legal/to next state/from Locked to Finished/governor,538349055,1370780,11626
+Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 1 cosigners and 5 effects/legal/to next state/from Locked to Finished/governor,538349055,1370780,11659
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 1 cosigners and 5 effects/legal/to next state/from Locked to Finished/authority,15806303,48240,5227
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 1 cosigners and 5 effects/legal/to failed state/from Draft to Finished/proposal,425387286,1154121,11221
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 1 cosigners and 5 effects/legal/to failed state/from Draft to Finished/stake,130046736,336404,7127
@@ -153,9 +153,9 @@ Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 1 cosigners and 5 effects/illegal/ambigu
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 1 cosigners and 5 effects/illegal/to next state too late/from Draft/stake,129324200,334140,7127
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 1 cosigners and 5 effects/illegal/to next state too late/from VotingReady/stake,130046736,336404,7132
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 1 cosigners and 5 effects/illegal/to next state too late/from Locked/stake,180556487,455715,8284
-Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 1 cosigners and 5 effects/illegal/to next state too late/from Locked/governor,538349055,1370780,11626
+Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 1 cosigners and 5 effects/illegal/to next state too late/from Locked/governor,538349055,1370780,11659
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 1 cosigners and 5 effects/illegal/to next state too late/from Locked/authority,15806303,48240,5227
-Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 1 cosigners and 5 effects/illegal/altered output stake datum/from Locked/governor,538349055,1370780,11627
+Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 1 cosigners and 5 effects/illegal/altered output stake datum/from Locked/governor,538349055,1370780,11660
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 1 cosigners and 5 effects/illegal/altered output stake datum/from Locked/authority,15806303,48240,5228
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 1 cosigners and 5 effects/illegal/forget to mint GATs/proposal,497384086,1336237,11669
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 1 cosigners and 5 effects/illegal/forget to mint GATs/stake,167456328,430104,7573
@@ -176,7 +176,7 @@ Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 5 cosigners and 1 effects/legal/to next
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 5 cosigners and 1 effects/legal/to next state/from VotingReady to Locked/stake,130046736,336404,5794
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 5 cosigners and 1 effects/legal/to next state/from Locked to Finished/proposal,362399088,998542,10376
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 5 cosigners and 1 effects/legal/to next state/from Locked to Finished/stake,180556487,455715,6946
-Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 5 cosigners and 1 effects/legal/to next state/from Locked to Finished/governor,465864319,1173688,10289
+Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 5 cosigners and 1 effects/legal/to next state/from Locked to Finished/governor,465864319,1173688,10322
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 5 cosigners and 1 effects/legal/to next state/from Locked to Finished/authority,15806303,48240,3890
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 5 cosigners and 1 effects/legal/to failed state/from Draft to Finished/proposal,266151242,743817,9217
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 5 cosigners and 1 effects/legal/to failed state/from Draft to Finished/stake,130046736,336404,5789
@@ -194,9 +194,9 @@ Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 5 cosigners and 1 effects/illegal/ambigu
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 5 cosigners and 1 effects/illegal/to next state too late/from Draft/stake,546746396,1437604,8178
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 5 cosigners and 1 effects/illegal/to next state too late/from VotingReady/stake,130046736,336404,5794
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 5 cosigners and 1 effects/illegal/to next state too late/from Locked/stake,180556487,455715,6946
-Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 5 cosigners and 1 effects/illegal/to next state too late/from Locked/governor,465864319,1173688,10289
+Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 5 cosigners and 1 effects/illegal/to next state too late/from Locked/governor,465864319,1173688,10322
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 5 cosigners and 1 effects/illegal/to next state too late/from Locked/authority,15806303,48240,3890
-Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 5 cosigners and 1 effects/illegal/altered output stake datum/from Locked/governor,465864319,1173688,10290
+Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 5 cosigners and 1 effects/illegal/altered output stake datum/from Locked/governor,465864319,1173688,10323
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 5 cosigners and 1 effects/illegal/altered output stake datum/from Locked/authority,15806303,48240,3891
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 5 cosigners and 1 effects/illegal/forget to mint GATs/proposal,338148042,925933,9664
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 5 cosigners and 1 effects/illegal/forget to mint GATs/stake,167456328,430104,6234
@@ -217,7 +217,7 @@ Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 5 cosigners and 2 effects/legal/to next
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 5 cosigners and 2 effects/legal/to next state/from VotingReady to Locked/stake,130046736,336404,6187
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 5 cosigners and 2 effects/legal/to next state/from Locked to Finished/proposal,407800436,1116634,10967
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 5 cosigners and 2 effects/legal/to next state/from Locked to Finished/stake,180556487,455715,7340
-Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 5 cosigners and 2 effects/legal/to next state/from Locked to Finished/governor,485782490,1228133,10683
+Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 5 cosigners and 2 effects/legal/to next state/from Locked to Finished/governor,485782490,1228133,10716
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 5 cosigners and 2 effects/legal/to next state/from Locked to Finished/authority,15806303,48240,4284
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 5 cosigners and 2 effects/legal/to failed state/from Draft to Finished/proposal,311552590,861909,9807
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 5 cosigners and 2 effects/legal/to failed state/from Draft to Finished/stake,130046736,336404,6182
@@ -235,9 +235,9 @@ Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 5 cosigners and 2 effects/illegal/ambigu
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 5 cosigners and 2 effects/illegal/to next state too late/from Draft/stake,546746396,1437604,8572
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 5 cosigners and 2 effects/illegal/to next state too late/from VotingReady/stake,130046736,336404,6187
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 5 cosigners and 2 effects/illegal/to next state too late/from Locked/stake,180556487,455715,7340
-Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 5 cosigners and 2 effects/illegal/to next state too late/from Locked/governor,485782490,1228133,10683
+Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 5 cosigners and 2 effects/illegal/to next state too late/from Locked/governor,485782490,1228133,10716
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 5 cosigners and 2 effects/illegal/to next state too late/from Locked/authority,15806303,48240,4284
-Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 5 cosigners and 2 effects/illegal/altered output stake datum/from Locked/governor,485782490,1228133,10684
+Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 5 cosigners and 2 effects/illegal/altered output stake datum/from Locked/governor,485782490,1228133,10717
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 5 cosigners and 2 effects/illegal/altered output stake datum/from Locked/authority,15806303,48240,4285
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 5 cosigners and 2 effects/illegal/forget to mint GATs/proposal,383549390,1044025,10255
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 5 cosigners and 2 effects/illegal/forget to mint GATs/stake,167456328,430104,6628
@@ -258,7 +258,7 @@ Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 5 cosigners and 5 effects/legal/to next
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 5 cosigners and 5 effects/legal/to next state/from VotingReady to Locked/stake,130046736,336404,7368
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 5 cosigners and 5 effects/legal/to next state/from Locked to Finished/proposal,544004480,1470910,12737
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 5 cosigners and 5 effects/legal/to next state/from Locked to Finished/stake,180556487,455715,8520
-Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 5 cosigners and 5 effects/legal/to next state/from Locked to Finished/governor,545537003,1391468,11863
+Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 5 cosigners and 5 effects/legal/to next state/from Locked to Finished/governor,545537003,1391468,11896
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 5 cosigners and 5 effects/legal/to next state/from Locked to Finished/authority,15806303,48240,5464
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 5 cosigners and 5 effects/legal/to failed state/from Draft to Finished/proposal,447756634,1216185,11578
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 5 cosigners and 5 effects/legal/to failed state/from Draft to Finished/stake,130046736,336404,7363
@@ -276,9 +276,9 @@ Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 5 cosigners and 5 effects/illegal/ambigu
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 5 cosigners and 5 effects/illegal/to next state too late/from Draft/stake,546746396,1437604,9752
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 5 cosigners and 5 effects/illegal/to next state too late/from VotingReady/stake,130046736,336404,7368
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 5 cosigners and 5 effects/illegal/to next state too late/from Locked/stake,180556487,455715,8520
-Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 5 cosigners and 5 effects/illegal/to next state too late/from Locked/governor,545537003,1391468,11863
+Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 5 cosigners and 5 effects/illegal/to next state too late/from Locked/governor,545537003,1391468,11896
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 5 cosigners and 5 effects/illegal/to next state too late/from Locked/authority,15806303,48240,5464
-Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 5 cosigners and 5 effects/illegal/altered output stake datum/from Locked/governor,545537003,1391468,11864
+Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 5 cosigners and 5 effects/illegal/altered output stake datum/from Locked/governor,545537003,1391468,11897
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 5 cosigners and 5 effects/illegal/altered output stake datum/from Locked/authority,15806303,48240,5465
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 5 cosigners and 5 effects/illegal/forget to mint GATs/proposal,519753434,1398301,12026
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 5 cosigners and 5 effects/illegal/forget to mint GATs/stake,167456328,430104,7809
@@ -299,7 +299,7 @@ Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 10 cosigners and 1 effects/legal/to next
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 10 cosigners and 1 effects/legal/to next state/from VotingReady to Locked/stake,130046736,336404,6095
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 10 cosigners and 1 effects/legal/to next state/from Locked to Finished/proposal,390360773,1076122,10828
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 10 cosigners and 1 effects/legal/to next state/from Locked to Finished/stake,180556487,455715,7247
-Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 10 cosigners and 1 effects/legal/to next state/from Locked to Finished/governor,474849254,1199548,10590
+Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 10 cosigners and 1 effects/legal/to next state/from Locked to Finished/governor,474849254,1199548,10623
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 10 cosigners and 1 effects/legal/to next state/from Locked to Finished/authority,15806303,48240,4191
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 10 cosigners and 1 effects/legal/to failed state/from Draft to Finished/proposal,294112927,821397,9669
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 10 cosigners and 1 effects/legal/to failed state/from Draft to Finished/stake,130046736,336404,6090
@@ -317,9 +317,9 @@ Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 10 cosigners and 1 effects/illegal/ambig
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 10 cosigners and 1 effects/illegal/to next state too late/from Draft/stake,1161583697,3085109,11466
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 10 cosigners and 1 effects/illegal/to next state too late/from VotingReady/stake,130046736,336404,6095
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 10 cosigners and 1 effects/illegal/to next state too late/from Locked/stake,180556487,455715,7247
-Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 10 cosigners and 1 effects/illegal/to next state too late/from Locked/governor,474849254,1199548,10590
+Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 10 cosigners and 1 effects/illegal/to next state too late/from Locked/governor,474849254,1199548,10623
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 10 cosigners and 1 effects/illegal/to next state too late/from Locked/authority,15806303,48240,4191
-Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 10 cosigners and 1 effects/illegal/altered output stake datum/from Locked/governor,474849254,1199548,10591
+Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 10 cosigners and 1 effects/illegal/altered output stake datum/from Locked/governor,474849254,1199548,10624
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 10 cosigners and 1 effects/illegal/altered output stake datum/from Locked/authority,15806303,48240,4192
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 10 cosigners and 1 effects/illegal/forget to mint GATs/proposal,366109727,1003513,10117
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 10 cosigners and 1 effects/illegal/forget to mint GATs/stake,167456328,430104,6536
@@ -340,7 +340,7 @@ Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 10 cosigners and 2 effects/legal/to next
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 10 cosigners and 2 effects/legal/to next state/from VotingReady to Locked/stake,130046736,336404,6488
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 10 cosigners and 2 effects/legal/to next state/from Locked to Finished/proposal,435762121,1194214,11418
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 10 cosigners and 2 effects/legal/to next state/from Locked to Finished/stake,180556487,455715,7641
-Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 10 cosigners and 2 effects/legal/to next state/from Locked to Finished/governor,494767425,1253993,10984
+Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 10 cosigners and 2 effects/legal/to next state/from Locked to Finished/governor,494767425,1253993,11017
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 10 cosigners and 2 effects/legal/to next state/from Locked to Finished/authority,15806303,48240,4585
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 10 cosigners and 2 effects/legal/to failed state/from Draft to Finished/proposal,339514275,939489,10258
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 10 cosigners and 2 effects/legal/to failed state/from Draft to Finished/stake,130046736,336404,6483
@@ -358,9 +358,9 @@ Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 10 cosigners and 2 effects/illegal/ambig
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 10 cosigners and 2 effects/illegal/to next state too late/from Draft/stake,1161583697,3085109,11859
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 10 cosigners and 2 effects/illegal/to next state too late/from VotingReady/stake,130046736,336404,6488
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 10 cosigners and 2 effects/illegal/to next state too late/from Locked/stake,180556487,455715,7641
-Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 10 cosigners and 2 effects/illegal/to next state too late/from Locked/governor,494767425,1253993,10984
+Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 10 cosigners and 2 effects/illegal/to next state too late/from Locked/governor,494767425,1253993,11017
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 10 cosigners and 2 effects/illegal/to next state too late/from Locked/authority,15806303,48240,4585
-Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 10 cosigners and 2 effects/illegal/altered output stake datum/from Locked/governor,494767425,1253993,10985
+Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 10 cosigners and 2 effects/illegal/altered output stake datum/from Locked/governor,494767425,1253993,11018
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 10 cosigners and 2 effects/illegal/altered output stake datum/from Locked/authority,15806303,48240,4586
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 10 cosigners and 2 effects/illegal/forget to mint GATs/proposal,411511075,1121605,10706
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 10 cosigners and 2 effects/illegal/forget to mint GATs/stake,167456328,430104,6929
@@ -381,7 +381,7 @@ Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 10 cosigners and 5 effects/legal/to next
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 10 cosigners and 5 effects/legal/to next state/from VotingReady to Locked/stake,130046736,336404,7669
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 10 cosigners and 5 effects/legal/to next state/from Locked to Finished/proposal,571966165,1548490,13190
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 10 cosigners and 5 effects/legal/to next state/from Locked to Finished/stake,180556487,455715,8822
-Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 10 cosigners and 5 effects/legal/to next state/from Locked to Finished/governor,554521938,1417328,12165
+Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 10 cosigners and 5 effects/legal/to next state/from Locked to Finished/governor,554521938,1417328,12198
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 10 cosigners and 5 effects/legal/to next state/from Locked to Finished/authority,15806303,48240,5765
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 10 cosigners and 5 effects/legal/to failed state/from Draft to Finished/proposal,475718319,1293765,12030
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 10 cosigners and 5 effects/legal/to failed state/from Draft to Finished/stake,130046736,336404,7664
@@ -399,9 +399,9 @@ Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 10 cosigners and 5 effects/illegal/ambig
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 10 cosigners and 5 effects/illegal/to next state too late/from Draft/stake,1161583697,3085109,13040
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 10 cosigners and 5 effects/illegal/to next state too late/from VotingReady/stake,130046736,336404,7669
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 10 cosigners and 5 effects/illegal/to next state too late/from Locked/stake,180556487,455715,8822
-Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 10 cosigners and 5 effects/illegal/to next state too late/from Locked/governor,554521938,1417328,12165
+Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 10 cosigners and 5 effects/illegal/to next state too late/from Locked/governor,554521938,1417328,12198
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 10 cosigners and 5 effects/illegal/to next state too late/from Locked/authority,15806303,48240,5765
-Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 10 cosigners and 5 effects/illegal/altered output stake datum/from Locked/governor,554521938,1417328,12166
+Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 10 cosigners and 5 effects/illegal/altered output stake datum/from Locked/governor,554521938,1417328,12199
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 10 cosigners and 5 effects/illegal/altered output stake datum/from Locked/authority,15806303,48240,5766
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 10 cosigners and 5 effects/illegal/forget to mint GATs/proposal,547715119,1475881,12478
 Agora/Proposal/validator/advancing/with 10 cosigners and 5 effects/illegal/forget to mint GATs/stake,167456328,430104,8110
@@ -574,5 +574,4 @@ Agora/Treasury/Validator/Positive/Allows for effect changes,31277082,80782,1450
 Agora/AuthorityToken/singleAuthorityTokenBurned/Correct simple,20570665,54655,725
 Agora/AuthorityToken/singleAuthorityTokenBurned/Correct many inputs,32757063,87013,825
 Agora/Governor/policy/totally legal,60002734,167736,2268
-Agora/Governor/validator/GATs minting,255848615,684194,8883
+Agora/Governor/validator/mutate/legal,100216324,268169,8154
-Agora/Governor/validator/mutate governor state,93971983,261537,8356